Friday, February 20, 2015

The defeat of the world: why Ukrainian security forces left Debaltseve – RBC

The defeat of the world: why Ukrainian security forces left Debaltseve – RBC

The output of the boiler

On Wednesday Debaltseve came under the control of the breakaway militias DNR and LC. On the capture of the eastern part of the city, they said on Tuesday.

Ukrainian military denied environment groups and the captivity of Ukrainian soldiers. President of Ukraine Poroshenko, according to Ukrainian experts, standing in front of a difficult choice: to attack and try to unlock Debaltseve, which undermined the Minsk Agreement on February 12, or to begin withdrawing troops that could be negatively perceived by the public as another military setback after losing Donetsk airport and delivery Ilovaysk.

On Wednesday afternoon Poroshenko arrived in the area of ​​anti-terrorist operations, where he said that environment groups was not, and by Wednesday morning the armed forces of Ukraine together with the National Guard under the operation for the conclusion of the divisions of Debaltseve. Poroshenko called the operation “a planned and organized.” Debaltseve, an important railway junction, left, according to his data, 80% of the parts: the soldiers came the 128th Brigade of the units of the 30th Brigade, the remains of the 25th and the 40th Battalion, Special Forces, the National Guard, the police.

The fact that the military came out completely with weaponry, according to Poroshenko, proves that Debaltseve was not in the environment, and the whole operation – convincing proof of the combat capability of the armed forces and the effectiveness of the military command. Delay in withdrawal adviser to President of Ukraine Yuri Biryukov on Facebook explained that the forces ATO destroyed railway junction.

According to Poroshenko, the group consisted of 2,000 soldiers, injuring 30 people. However, representatives of DNR gave different figures: according to Deputy Defense Minister of breakaway DNR Edward Basurina, was surrounded by up to 10 000 Ukrainian soldiers, killing about 3000. According to Russian military experts, Debaltseve were 3-4 thousand Ukrainian military.

Most of the groups mentioned Poroshenko divided by the militia, and some have surrendered or surrendering, DNR spokesman Denis Pushilin Donetsk news agency. Data for the prisoners also differ. The head of the breakaway LC Igor Carpenter said that in the area Debaltseve Tuesday surrendered 104 soldiers of the Ukrainian army, about 30 sent to hospital for treatment.

How did debaltsevsky boiler

September 5, 2014

At the end of the first Minsk Agreement has been fixed line of demarcation, which was planned to withdraw from the artillery and heavy weapons. In the area Debaltseve (an important transportation hub) front line was uneven: the city and the number of settlements around it were under the control of the Armed Forces of Ukraine, but this site to “wedge” in the DNI position militias and LC.

25-28 January 2015

Minsk Agreement violated regularly, and in early January, fighting on south-east of Ukraine sharply intensified. After the shelling of Mariupol (24 January), the militia announced the beginning of military operations under Debaltseve. January 25 reported attacks on Uglegorsk, Trinity and Svetlodarsk January 26, began fighting for Popasnaya. It was in those days began to talk about the environment and Ukrainian troops debaltsevskom boiler. 28th it was reported that the troops DNR entrenched in the north-eastern part of Debaltseve.

9 February 2015

Deputy Defense Minister Eduard Basurin DNR announced the capture of the village militias Logvinova, which is directly adjacent to the highway connecting the city Debaltseve Artemovsk Donetsk region (controlled by Ukrainian law enforcers).

February 12, 2015

The battalion commander “Donbass” the National Guard of Ukraine Semen Semenchenko said that the APU power control in the way of Debaltseve Artemivs’k through settlements Lozove and Lugano (detour Logvinova). “Now neither of which boiler is out of the question,” – said Semenchenko.

On the same day the second Minsk signed an agreement, according to which at 0:00 on February 15 side were to cease fire. Chapter DNR Alexander Zakharchenko said that the militias are ready to stop fighting everywhere except Debaltseve, the area which they consider its internal territory. “In Minsk agreements Debaltseve not a word,” – said Zakharchenko.

February 16

Manual DNR said it would provide the Ukrainian military who are in debaltsevskom boiler “green corridor”. Vice-Speaker of the National Council of the breakaway republic Denis Pushilin said that security forces can leave Debaltseve without weapons and equipment.

February 17

The militia said about taking the train station and the building Debaltseve city police department. However, according to Chief of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Ukraine in Donetsk region Vyacheslav Abros’kina, the police left the partially destroyed building on his orders. During the day, representatives of the DNR and reported LC control 80% of the Debaltseve and the capture of about 300 Ukrainian troops. During one of the battles DNR leader Alexander Zakharchenko was slightly wounded in the leg.

Political Results

«These actions were confounded Russia, which only yesterday demanded that the Ukrainian military to lay down arms, raise the white flag and surrender, “- said Poroshenko. Russian President Vladimir Putin on Tuesday, while in Hungary, expressed the hope that “the responsible persons in the Ukrainian leadership will not interfere with the Ukrainian army soldiers lay down their arms if they are not able to take this important decision and give such an order.” Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov on Wednesday at a press conference in Moscow said that the Ukrainian side at the talks in Minsk last week to withdraw from Debaltseve, but without weapons – out with guns militia would not have agreed, but seemed to Poroshenko.

There was another tragedy, the Ukrainian leadership should have been used to derive the expected environment of thousands of troops, commented Ukrainian political analyst Mikhail Pogrebinsky . He expects staffing solutions to the Chief of the General Staff Viktor Muzhenko: on Wednesday evening Poroshenko must hold a meeting of the National Security and Defense. According Pogrebinskii, get out before Debaltseve meant to give Kiev territory whose one a long time did not dispute until militias in January and have not started to attack him, and did not continue after the February Minsk Agreement.

unexpected outcome: both Ukrainian troops withdrew Debaltseve Gallery   The situation in the Debaltseve where Ukrainian troops were in the environment, Feb. 18 got its development. President of Ukraine Poroshenko said that the city came out 80% of units Ukrainian troops. According to him, he persona lly gave the corresponding order. In this case, Kiev continues to assert that there is no environment in Debaltseve was not. Poroshenko said that the security forces left the city with all the equipment and weapons. According to him, the expected output of two columns. Poroshenko also flew to the zone of the military operation in the city of Artemovsk where profits emerging from Debaltseve military. Militia, in turn, confirmed by the data of the partial withdrawal of the Ukrainian security services Debaltseve. However, they claimed, came those “who was able to infiltrate.” According to them, there is still surrounded by a large number of Ukrainian soldiers.
          
View 14 photos

Kiev today still retains an interest in a temporary truce, as and militia, so both sides will try to keep the silent mode and the next, the alleged agreements Ming step – take arms; but the process will be difficult, especially in the absence of effective control, said Pogrebinsky. Kiev, in his opinion, appreciates the likelihood of obtaining weapons from the United States and therefore it wants to wait. OSCE representatives on Sunday tried to reach Debaltseve, but could not do it: the militia said that they could not guarantee the safety of observers.

The representative of the Ministry of Defense DNR Edward Basurin on Wednesday announced the beginning of the withdrawal of heavy weapons from Elenovka, Telmanovo and Yasinovataya in the Donetsk region.

Minsk Agreement – a realistic scenario, a temporary freeze of the conflict, that is, when the first (ceasefire) and second (removal of the arms) points in all the concerned capitals relieved, says Russian political analyst Alexei Makarkin. How long will this freeze is impossible to say, especially in the absence of strict international control, continues Makarkin. Now both sides – Ukraine, breakaway republics with Russia – based on the fact that the economy will collapse before the opponent.

Minsk agreement from the beginning were a dead end, at best, be able to observe a ceasefire and solve the problem of the minimum Ceasefire , the rest does not make sense to say, until there is only in the region of the OSCE, we need new negotiations involving peacekeepers, summarizes the Ukrainian political analyst Vladimir Fesenko.

LikeTweet

No comments:

Post a Comment